Caught in the Crossfire by Matina Jewell

Matina Jewell’s Caught in the Crossfire is one of those books that sits somewhere between military memoir, personal survival story and an examination of the difficulties of modern peacekeeping. Jewell was an Australian Army officer serving as a United Nations military observer in Lebanon during the 2006 conflict between Israel and Hezbollah. What began as a peacekeeping deployment became something considerably more dangerous when fighting erupted around the observers and the protections supposedly provided by their United Nations status became increasingly uncertain.

Jewell came to the mission with considerable military experience. She was not an inexperienced officer suddenly exposed to the realities of conflict, and this background gives greater weight to her description of the deterioration of the situation around her. She understood military risk, operational procedures and the limitations under which peacekeepers worked, yet the conflict placed the United Nations observers in circumstances where their ability to influence events was extremely limited.

One of the great strengths of the book is its depiction of peacekeeping as something considerably more complicated than the term sometimes suggests. There is a tendency to imagine peacekeepers operating between two sides that have already decided, however reluctantly, to stop fighting. Jewell’s experience demonstrates the very different reality faced when international observers remain in an area where the participants are actively conducting military operations. United Nations markings might identify an observer, but they cannot provide physical protection when artillery, missiles and air strikes are being employed nearby.

The military observer’s position was particularly difficult because observation depended upon remaining close enough to events to understand what was occurring while avoiding becoming part of those events. Jewell describes an environment in which the boundaries between observer, participant and potential casualty became dangerously thin. Decisions that might appear straightforward when considered from a distant headquarters became much more complicated when made by individuals surrounded by an active conflict and possessing only a limited understanding of what might happen next.

The central event around which much of the book revolves is the destruction of the United Nations observation post at Khiam in southern Lebanon in July 2006. Four United Nations military observers were killed when the position was struck during Israeli operations. Jewell knew the men involved and had herself served at the post, giving the incident a personal dimension that cannot be obtained simply by reading an official report or a conventional history of the conflict. The deaths are not merely statistics within a larger war but the loss of colleagues and friends whose personalities and relationships mattered to those who survived them.

Jewell’s own situation was already extremely serious. She suffered severe injuries while attempting to leave her position during the fighting and subsequently faced a difficult evacuation. Her description of injury, vulnerability and dependence upon others provides some of the most powerful material in the book. The military environment that had previously been understood through training, procedure and professional responsibility suddenly became intensely personal, while survival depended not simply upon competence but upon circumstance, assistance and the willingness of others to take considerable risks on her behalf.

There is also a valuable multinational dimension to the story. United Nations operations bring together personnel from different armed forces, cultures and military traditions and require them to work within a common structure. Jewell demonstrates how quickly professional relationships can become intensely personal when individuals face danger together. Nationality becomes less important than competence, trust and the knowledge that the person beside you may eventually be responsible for keeping you alive.

The book is particularly useful because it raises uncomfortable questions about the practical limitations of United Nations peacekeeping. Observers can report violations, record military activity and provide information to higher headquarters, but their ability to stop determined belligerents is often extremely limited. The presence of international personnel does not necessarily prevent escalation, nor does it guarantee that those personnel will remain outside the conflict. Jewell’s experience provides a stark demonstration of the distance that can exist between the theoretical purpose of a peacekeeping mission and the circumstances encountered by those expected to carry it out.

Another important part of the book concerns what happened after Jewell returned to Australia. Physical survival did not mark the end of her experience. Serious injury brought rehabilitation and the difficult process of rebuilding a life that had been dramatically altered. The transition from operational soldier to injured veteran forms an important part of the narrative because it reminds the reader that the consequences of military service frequently continue long after an individual has been removed from immediate danger.

It was this personal dimension that I found particularly effective. Military history understandably tends to concentrate upon campaigns, commanders, formations and outcomes, but those structures can sometimes obscure what war actually does to individuals. Jewell’s account brings that individual experience to the foreground without losing sight of the military environment that created it. Her recovery is therefore not an appendix to the story of Lebanon but part of the same story.

The greatest strength of Caught in the Crossfire is its immediacy. Jewell was there, knew the people involved and experienced the consequences personally. Her account is particularly effective when dealing with uncertainty and the limited information available to individuals on the ground. War is rarely experienced with the clarity that later histories sometimes impose upon it. Decisions have to be made before all the information is available, dangers are not always recognised until they have become immediate, and apparently routine circumstances can deteriorate with frightening speed.

Normally I tend to prefer military history that provides considerable detail about operations, units, commanders and command decisions, and Caught in the Crossfire is not that sort of book. The wider strategic objectives of Israel and Hezbollah, the political background to the conflict and the detailed conduct of military operations provide the setting rather than the principal subject. Yet in this case I did not find that a significant weakness. The narrower personal perspective is precisely what gives the book its strength.

Indeed, attempting to turn Jewell’s account into a comprehensive history of the 2006 Lebanon War would probably have weakened it. There are plenty of other works in which the broader political and military dimensions of the conflict can be explored. What Jewell provides is something different: an understanding of what those larger events looked like to one Australian officer who suddenly found herself caught within them.

I also appreciated the fact that the story does not conveniently finish with evacuation from Lebanon. Jewell follows the consequences home, where recovery created another struggle of a very different kind. The movement from an operational environment into rehabilitation could easily have felt like a separate story, but instead it reinforces one of the book’s central messages. Military service can continue to shape an individual’s life long after the shooting has stopped.

I enjoyed this very much. Caught in the Crossfire combines military experience, peacekeeping, survival and personal reflection without pretending to be a conventional campaign history. I found Jewell’s account engaging precisely because the larger conflict is viewed from ground level, where information was incomplete, control was limited and the consequences of decisions were immediate and personal.

Matina Jewell has produced a powerful account of an extraordinary experience, but its value extends beyond the remarkable circumstances of her own story. The book provides an insight into the vulnerability of peacekeepers caught between forces they have neither the authority nor the military power to control, while also reminding us that the human consequences of conflict continue long after an individual has left the battlefield. I enjoyed Caught in the Crossfire considerably and would readily recommend it, particularly to readers interested in the Australian military experience, modern peacekeeping and the human realities that sit behind the more familiar histories of campaigns and operations.

Rating: 4.5 out of 5.

Please leave a comment