The Amazing SAS by Ian McPhedran sits somewhere between investigative journalism, institutional history, and popular military narrative. First published in 2005, the book arrived at a moment when the Australian SAS Regiment occupied a growing place in Australian public imagination following deployments to East Timor, Afghanistan, Iraq, domestic counterterrorism duties, and the post 9/11 security environment.

The great strength of the book is access. McPhedran was one of Australia’s most connected defence journalists and clearly enjoyed substantial cooperation from senior officers, political figures, and serving SAS personnel. Interviews with figures such as Peter Cosgrove, Peter Leahy, Gus Gilmore, Tim McOwan, and serving soldiers provide immediacy and institutional perspective rarely available in Australian military publishing at the time.The result is a readable and often compelling account of selection, training culture, operational preparation, and the emotional pressures surrounding special operations service.
As narrative military journalism, the book works extremely well. McPhedran understands pacing and operational storytelling. The descriptions of selection courses, patrol preparation, small unit culture, and deployment cycles are engaging without collapsing entirely into sensationalism. The sections dealing with East Timor and the early Afghanistan deployments are particularly effective because they capture a transitional Australian Army moving from peacekeeping assumptions into the operational tempo of the War on Terror. Readers interested in the atmosphere and institutional mindset of the SAS during the early 2000s will find considerable value here.
The book also deserves credit for helping open Australian public discussion about special operations forces at a time when very little accessible material existed on the Australian SAS. Australian military publishing had often lagged behind British and American equivalents in presenting modern special forces history to a broader audience. Contemporary reviewers noted that little serious material had been written about the SAS before McPhedran’s work.
At the same time, the book’s greatest strength is also its greatest limitation. The access comes at a price. The narrative remains very close to the official perspective of the regiment and senior defence leadership. Even to frequently presenting the “official account” of controversial events and seldom subjects institutional claims to sustained critical analysis.
Another issue is the tone can occasionally drift toward admiration rather than examination. Operational failures, ambiguities, political complexities, and ethical tensions are generally softened or passed over quickly.
This means the book is best treated with some caution as it reflects the public image and institutional culture of the Australian SAS in the immediate post 9/11 era rather than as a definitive analytical history. It captures how the regiment wished to be seen and how defence journalism of the period framed Australian special operations capability. In that sense it is historically valuable even where it lacks critical distance and must be treated with a keen analytical eye.
The operational coverage is also constrained by timing. Published before later Afghanistan controversies and subsequent war crimes inquiries transformed public understanding of Australian special operations, the book now reads partly as a snapshot of an earlier phase of public perception. Modern readers approaching it after the Brereton Inquiry will inevitably notice the absence of the harder questions that later emerged regarding operational culture, accountability, and the psychological pressures of repeated deployments. That is not entirely McPhedran’s fault; the book belongs to a specific historical moment.
Stylistically, McPhedran writes in a direct journalistic voice rather than an academic one. The prose is fast moving, accessible, and occasionally dramatic. Some readers will appreciate the momentum while others may find the tone occasionally too celebratory. It is not a deeply footnoted scholarly work in the style of official histories or operational monographs. Instead, it functions as narrative reportage with strong insider access.
Overall, The Amazing SAS remains an important early popular account of the Australian SAS Regiment. It is readable, informative, and often gripping, but it should be approached with awareness of its institutional proximity and limited critical distance. As a piece of defence journalism and a cultural snapshot of the Australian military in the early War on Terror period, it remains highly worthwhile. Not my style but OK if it is something you are interested in.

























































