A review: “Roden Cutler, V.C.” by Colleen McCullough

Colleen McCullough’s writing usually isn’t my favorite; I often find it lengthy and wordy. However, in her first nonfiction work, she has done well. She tells the life story of a great Australian and explores what defines a man.

Colleen McCullough’s “Roden Cutler, V.C.” is a super interesting and detailed biography that dives into the life of Sir Roden Cutler, an awesome Australian war hero and former Governor of New South Wales. This book was McCullough’s first shot at non-fiction, giving us an “energetic, entertaining, and enlightening” look at a guy whose honesty and down-to-earth attitude were as impressive as all the cool stuff he achieved.

Cutler, seriously wounded, is carried from the battlefield by French prisoners of war

McCullough’s biography dives into the idea of heroism with Cutler and other Victoria Cross winners, shining a light on their selfless acts. It walks us through Cutler’s life from his childhood in Manly, to his military days in World War II, then into his diplomatic gig, and finally his time as Governor. The book really highlights his strong sense of duty, the smart choices he made, and how he could effortlessly connect with all sorts of people.

Cutler’s seen as a bit of a legend in a pretty selfish time, embodying what it means to be dedicated and principled. “Roden Cutler, V.C.” dives into Australia’s history and takes a good look at modern heroes, really making us think about whether selfless service still matters these days.

More Than Just a Biography. “Roden Cutler, V.C.” isn’t your average bio. It dives into the life of an incredible person while also chatting about what it means to be Australian, heroism, and what makes a true leader. This book is not just about history; it’s also a cool take on what really matters. I liked it.

Rating: 4 out of 5.

For more information on Roden Cutler see my post here.

A review “Montgomery of Alamein” by Alun Chalfont

First published in April 1976, this an engaging take on the biography of Bernard Montgomery, the British WW II commander. This book skips over Monty’s private papers but does a great job offering cool insights into who he was and how he operated. The battle scenes aren’t the main highlight, but Chalfont does mention how the British had the upper hand in North Africa and how Montgomery struggled to take down Rommel as the Germans were pulling back, which really shows the tricky nature of war.

Plus, the whole Overlord invasion business gets discussed mainly through the squabbles among the Allies, which just goes to show how tough it can be to work together in a multinational team. The connection Montgomery had with his troops is pretty clear; they respected him even though he could come off as a bit rough around the edges. After experiencing WW I, he was all about saving lives and making sure even the lower ranks knew what was going on in each operation, which built a supportive vibe among his men. He understood logistics and tech really well—although he doesn’t dive deep into those topics—which were crucial in his game plan.

Chalfont makes a solid case that Monty wasn’t just some overly cautious or stiff general; he never actually lost a battle after North Africa, which is impressive. His psychological background gets some serious attention too, causing quite a stir in Britain, where people found it both critical and fair. He had a tough upbringing and was known for being a bit brutal at Sandhurst, but then he experienced a heartfelt yet tragic marriage that ended with his wife’s heartbreaking death, leaving a mark on him. Montgomery had “a certain epicene quality” and a fondness for young men, which added more depth to his character. All in all, this self-righteous but highly skilled leader’s ability to tackle the challenges of wartime leadership is captured skillfully by Chalfont, who pulls it all together in a way that’s both fascinating and believable.

Baron Arthur Gwynne Jones Chalfont became a second lieutenant on 2 November 1940, served in Burma from 1941 to 1944, and received an emergency commission in the Royal Armoured Corps as a lieutenant on 1 January 1943. He continued his military career post-war, receiving a substantive lieutenant’s commission in 1946, was promoted to captain in December 1950, and to major in December 1953. He participated in anti-terrorist campaigns and won the Military Cross in August 1957 for leading a successful ambush against communist insurgents in Malaysia during the Malayan Emergency. The citation read:

“For gallantry and relentless determination during a period of eighteen months in command of his company in jungle operations. By his personal share in difficult, hazardous and successful operations, he set a fine example to those around him.”

Gwynne Jones was promoted to lieutenant-colonel in 1960, received the OBE in 1961, and retired in 1961 with the honorary rank of lieutenant-colonel.

This book is more of a personal rather than a military biography. First published in I enjoyed the personal side of things that examines “Monty’s” controversial lone wolf personality. It reflects the challenges of navigating relationships with coworkers while highlighting consistent insensitivity.

Rating: 3.5 out of 5.